First Samuel’s Investment Matters
This week’s perspective
A Growth Scare and the AI cycle
Craig ShepherdChief Investment Officer, First Samuel
About 13 minutes
Copyright 2026 First Samuel Limited
The sustainability of the extraordinary investment boom surrounding artificial intelligence remains a top concern for financial markets. The scale of spending on data centres, electricity infrastructure and associated technology has been enormous, supporting not only technology share prices but also the prices of commodities expected to benefit from this investment. Yet questions about the eventual returns on this spending, its financing and the reliability of increasingly complex technology are becoming harder to ignore. The Nvidia scandal did not help!
This month, the tech-heavy NASDAQ has fallen 4 per cent and is down almost 12 per cent since its early October 2026 highs. The broader US market (-8.2 per cent) has fared slightly better, with the equal-weighted SP500 index (a tilt in clients’ International sub-portfolio designed to minimise exposure to expensive mega-cap stocks) down only 3.8 per cent from its highs.
The market
FYTD: ASX and Wall Street
The week: ASX and Wall Street
Cartoon: Patrick Cook
Copper provides a particularly interesting illustration of the breadth of the impacts. Expectations of persistent, potentially long-term copper shortages have helped drive a remarkable price increase, supported by forecasts of enormous demand from AI infrastructure, electrification, and electricity networks. The recent sharp decline in copper prices reminds us that even powerful structural trends remain vulnerable to shifting expectations and the traditional economic cycle. Copper has fallen 15 per cent in a month as the AI trade reversed, with implications for the ASX.
LME Copper prices – last 12 months
More importantly, the retreat in enthusiasm for these investment themes is exposing the weakness of the broader global economy. The AI investment boom has provided an important source of growth and optimism at a time when much of the world has been struggling with persistent inflation, elevated interest rates and subdued economic activity. It has helped sustain the expectation that productivity improvements and new investment might eventually provide a way out of this uncomfortable combination. The risk for the market facing weaker capex and higher rates is a Growth Shock.
The difficulty is that inflation remains persistent, while the consequences of higher interest rates are becoming increasingly apparent. Central banks are confronting an unenviable choice: maintain restrictive monetary policy and risk further economic weakness, or ease financial conditions before inflation has been convincingly contained. There are few painless solutions.
The prospect of weaker growth, without the certainty of a rapid reduction in interest rates, is beginning to generate a broader growth scare. Recent concerns about technology failures and the reliability of complex systems have only added to the uncertainty surrounding the investment cycle. These scares can often be mid-cycle corrections with future rebounds, or occasionally wholesale readjustments within markets, especially at the sectoral level.
Australia’s changing outlook
For Australia, these developments are particularly significant. BHP and Rio Tinto have benefited substantially from strong copper prices, and their large index weights mean changing commodity expectations can have an outsized impact on the broader Australian share market.
Despite our confidence in future demand, we have progressively reduced our copper exposure throughout the year, as the portfolio benefited from the appreciation in our holdings of Aurelia Metals, Sandfire Metals and Rio Tinto. At the beginning of this quarter, we were underweight copper.
Meanwhile, the Australian economy is providing its own evidence of weakening growth.
As we discussed last week, declining house prices are becoming an increasingly important influence on household confidence and spending. National dwelling values have now fallen for seven consecutive months and are 6.7% below their March peak. Higher mortgage costs, weaker household wealth and subdued consumer demand are increasingly affecting business conditions.
Thursday’s ABS employment figures added substantially to these concerns. The ABS reported a fall of 43,500 in employment in October, with the unemployment rate reaching 4.9%, its highest level in five years. There is undoubtedly some statistical noise in the monthly figures, but the underlying trend is weakening. Demand for new employees has been slowing, with job advertisement data reinforcing the picture of a less buoyant labour market.
Cartoon: Patrick Cook
We have three excellent charts from Barrenjoey Research to highlight the themes in employment. The first shows the percentage point change in unemployment. Despite concerns about statistical noise, the first chart now shows 5 consecutive months of rising unemployment.
Five consecutive rises in the unemployment rate is beginning to look like a trend
The second chart shows the movement in the underlying components of the labour force. The black line shows the percentage of the labour force that is a new entrant to the ranks of the employed. This is slowing. The green line shows the percentage of the labour force that is experiencing job losses; this remains remarkably low. The distinction is important – unemployment isn’t yet rising because of job cuts per se, despite sporadic headlines. The economy just isn’t generating enough to keep up with the population growth we are experiencing. With that context, we are surprised to see 90-day past-due arrears in home loans already at high levels.
Components of employment market changes
The third chart shows that rising unemployment is no longer just a Victorian issue. Despite Victoria leading the unemployment rate higher since 2022, recent months in New South Wales and Queensland indicate that not all can be blamed on the Education State.
The lift in the unemployment rate is broadening outside Victoria
This is important because the highest levels of 90-day past-due mortgage arrears for banks such as NAB were in Victoria 1.51% versus overall 1.19%, and Queensland only 0.63%.
This week’s ABS unemployment figures are significant for the market because they may simultaneously change the outlook for interest rates and reinforce concerns about economic growth. The likelihood of further Reserve Bank interest-rate increases has diminished, potentially providing welcome relief to households and businesses. However, the reason for this change is hardly encouraging: the economic slowdown is becoming more apparent.
One of the more surprising features of the Australian share market has been the continued relative strength of the major banks. Despite the growing risks to household finances, credit demand and economic activity, investors remain willing to pay substantial prices for Australia’s largest financial institutions.
This resilience stands in sharp contrast to the performance of smaller companies and, more recently, the major resource producers. It also highlights an increasingly important feature of the Australian market: the divergence between the valuations of the largest listed companies and much of the rest of the market.
The growing divide in Australian equities
Over the past year, we have repeatedly commented on the increasing concentration of Australian institutional investment in the largest listed companies.
The Your Future, Your Super performance-testing framework has contributed to this problem by encouraging the largest industry superannuation funds to remain close to prescribed market benchmarks. While the objective of protecting investors from persistently poor fund performance is entirely reasonable, the unintended consequence has been to discourage investment managers from taking meaningful positions away from the largest index constituents.
This matters particularly in Australia, where a relatively small number of companies account for a substantial proportion of the share market. Capital increasingly flows towards businesses because of their index weight rather than necessarily because they offer the best prospective returns.
The result is becoming more apparent. Larger companies have remained relatively expensive despite modest earnings growth, while many smaller businesses have experienced substantial valuation declines. Even before the recent correction, smaller Australian companies were trading at historically attractive valuations relative to larger companies on an enterprise-value-to-EBITDA basis. They have since become cheaper still.
Rising interest rates and passive flow have seen smaller companies derate in FYTD27
We had hoped that Treasurer Jim Chalmers’ review of the superannuation performance-testing arrangements would address some of these distortions. Unfortunately, the changes announced this week leave the central benchmark-driven incentives largely intact. The introduction of greater flexibility for certain emerging investments is welcome, but it does little to resolve the broader problem of index concentration.
We believe this is more than a sharemarket issue. Australia’s enormous pool of compulsory superannuation savings should be one of its greatest economic strengths. A system that encourages investment in established index constituents at the expense of smaller, potentially more productive businesses risks undermining capital formation, investment and longer-term productivity growth.
Increasing opportunities beneath the surface
Despite these concerns, we are becoming increasingly positive about opportunities within the Australian sharemarket. This is not necessarily a view about the direction of the overall index, which remains heavily influenced by a relatively small number of large, expensive companies. Rather, it reflects the growing divergence in valuations between the largest listed businesses and many smaller companies.
Across the smaller end of the market, we are finding businesses with attractive hard assets, strong free cash flow and valuable strategic positions trading at substantial discounts to what we consider reasonable long-term valuations. In some cases, share prices are below the value of tangible assets; in others, established businesses with recurring earnings are available at multiples that imply little prospect of future growth.
The surprisingly weak employment figures may prove important in changing this dynamic. While they reinforce concerns about the economy, they also reduce the likelihood of further RBA interest-rate increases. A pause in the tightening cycle, and greater confidence that interest rates have peaked, should provide some relief to smaller companies and encourage investors to recognise the value of their assets and future cash flows.
If Australian investors remain unwilling to recognise that value, others increasingly will. The continuing wave of takeover interest from international and strategic buyers highlights the opportunity created by depressed Australian valuations. Businesses and assets overlooked by domestic share market investors are proving considerably more appealing to buyers with longer investment horizons.
Our portfolio reflects a deliberate combination of attractive domestic assets and businesses with substantial international exposure. Alongside smaller Australian companies offering compelling valuations, we retain investments in globally focused businesses including James Hardie, Block, Life360 and QBE. These companies provide exposure to different industries, economic conditions and sources of earnings growth, reducing our dependence on the performance of the Australian economy.
We retain a substantial cash balance and are positioning the portfolio to take advantage of further opportunities. These cash levels have proven valuable this week, and when deployed, are anticipated to create further value.
While the economic outlook remains uncertain, we are increasingly encouraged by the prices at which we can acquire sound businesses with attractive assets, sustainable cash generation and genuine long-term prospects.
Our caution about the economic cycle is increasingly matched by optimism about the investment opportunities being created. Watch this space as we will be spending more of the cash on this over the next few months.
Company updates — The final stages of AGM season
Similar to previous weeks, we have continued to follow the remaining annual general meetings and investor presentations, highlighting developments relevant to the portfolio and our broader investment thinking. This week’s updates provide an interesting range of perspectives on the economic outlook, the opportunities to improve productivity and the increasingly different prices investors are prepared to pay for established businesses.
Woolworths (WOW) — Sales growth, productivity and the price of quality
Woolworths held its Investor Day this week, presenting an ambitious but credible strategy to increase sales, reduce costs and improve profitability. Woolworths is an outstanding Australian business, with enormous scale, a sophisticated distribution network, powerful customer relationships and considerable pricing power. The more difficult question is how much of its future success is already reflected in its share price.
Investor Days can have an excess of consultant speak and mission statements, but occasionally a slide makes a cynic pause. We liked the following graphic, which highlights the scope of real data that Woolworths is harnessing. Especially surprising that 8m people in the past year responded to the Woolworths’ Voice of the Customer survey. Your author was one of them, but I like surveys and stats; the other 8m demonstrated high-quality information collection.
Woolworths Investor Day – Impressive data set
Management is targeting an additional $10 billion in annual sales by FY29, equivalent to growth of approximately 4.5% annually. We regard this objective as eminently achievable, particularly given the outlook for persistent inflation, modest store expansion and the company’s ability to pass through higher costs. The strategy is built around a virtuous circle: stronger sales generate efficiencies, allowing further investment in prices, customer service and market share. The challenge is maintaining that momentum as competitors respond and consumers become increasingly price-conscious.
We suspect the opportunities to reduce cost are considerably greater than management’s current ambitions suggest. Despite substantial investment in technology and distribution, Woolworths is arguably no more efficient in its use of labour than it was before COVID. Like much of the Australian economy, it has struggled to translate investment and technological improvements into sustained growth in labour productivity. There is considerable scope to improve staff scheduling, store operations, distribution and online fulfilment. In a slowing economy, renewed management attention to controlling labour costs could provide an important source of earnings resilience, making Woolworths potentially attractive as a more defensive portfolio investment.
Perhaps the most interesting element of the presentation was the role of artificial intelligence. At our recent CIO presentation, much of the discussion focused on AI’s ability to reduce costs. Woolworths illustrates a broader opportunity: using AI both to improve productivity and to increase sales. Better inventory management, automated processes and more efficient fulfilment can reduce costs, while personalised shopping, improved product recommendations and digital customer engagement can increase spending and strengthen customer relationships.
An important unresolved question is how effectively Woolworths will manage customer value in an AI-driven retail environment. AI may improve its ability to understand customers, tailor offers and preserve pricing power. Equally, technology that makes prices more transparent and shopping comparisons easier could strengthen competition and transfer some of that value to consumers.
We believe Woolworths has strong prospects for sustainable earnings growth, with potential productivity gains that may be underestimated. However, at approximately 28.5 times forward earnings, investors are already paying a substantial premium for the business’s quality and resilience. Woolworths is an attractive company, particularly in a weakening economy, but the price remains an important consideration.
Emeco Holdings (EHL) — A disproportionate market reaction
Emeco’s AGM trading update saw its share price fall approximately 17% by early Friday, despite a relatively modest reduction in expected earnings. The mining equipment rental and maintenance business lowered its FY27 operating EBITDA outlook to $275–285 million, compared with approximately $293 million achieved in FY26. Importantly, almost all the reduction relates to delays in deploying equipment onto new projects, rather than any deterioration in underlying demand or operating conditions.
Indeed, the outlook for the second half of FY27 remains largely unchanged, with equipment utilisation expected to improve substantially. Management is targeting utilisation of approximately 90% in its surface fleet and 80% underground by year-end, underpinning its ambition to achieve a 20% return on capital in FY28.
The fall reversed much of the gains this financial year, yet it remains 10 per cent higher than June 30.
At around 7 times forecast earnings, just over 2 times FY28 EBITDA on an enterprise-value basis, and trading at a substantial discount to expected net tangible assets of at least $1.60 per share, Emeco remains exceptionally inexpensive. Its balance sheet is also strong, and the company continues to repurchase its own shares.
There is also an emerging question about the benefits of artificial intelligence for businesses built around physical assets. Much of the AI discussion has concentrated on software and knowledge-based work, but mining equipment operators may ultimately benefit from improved predictive maintenance, equipment utilisation, fleet deployment and labour productivity. For Emeco, even modest improvements in asset availability and operating efficiency could generate attractive incremental returns on its substantial capital base. The size and timing of these benefits remain uncertain, but they represent an interesting potential source of upside that is not central to current earnings expectations.
We regard the market’s reaction as another buying opportunity rather than a change in the investment case. In a week when smaller Australian companies attracted takeover interest from international buyers seeking to exploit depressed valuations, domestic investors’ willingness to sell a fundamentally sound business on such a modest change in earnings expectations highlights increasing opportunities in this market for patient investors.
Worley (WOR) — A mixed outlook
Worley also held its AGM this week, reaffirming guidance for mid-to-high-single-digit growth in revenue and underlying EBITA for FY27. Management described mixed operating conditions, with strength in North American LNG, energy infrastructure and resources offset by weakness in chemicals and ongoing disruption in the Middle East. Earnings are expected to be heavily weighted towards the second half, as delayed projects commence and activity recovers.
At approximately 13 times FY27 earnings, Worley looks relatively inexpensive, particularly given its substantial order book. However, the company has repeatedly disappointed investors, and management still needs to show that its strong pipeline can translate into improved profitability.
Continue the conversation
More perspectives.
Better-informed decisions.
Explore Investment Matters or speak with our team about the questions that matter to you.
Explore the full picture
Stock and market commentary from the Investment Matters series.
Browse the archiveRead the previous edition
UBS Australasia Conference — The great AI question
Read the articlePut your questions
in context
Discuss how the issues raised here relate to your circumstances.
Speak with First SamuelAI-generated illustrative image.
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.
No assurance or guarantee is given that any forecast, target or projection will be achieved. Forward-looking statements are based on assumptions and information available as at 20 November 2026 and are subject to risks, uncertainties and factors beyond First Samuel’s control. Actual outcomes may differ materially.
Any advice contained on this website is of a general nature only and has been prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Because of that, before acting on any advice on this website, you should consider whether the advice is appropriate for you having regard to your objectives, financial situation and needs.
Investment Matters is Craig Shepherd’s personal publication. The views expressed are his own and do not necessarily represent the views of First Samuel Limited. It is not financial product advice.